View by:







Ethics Influencing Science?

At this point we should see that ethical factors are beginning to influence the science. This variant on the second scenario appears to have a slight ethical advantage. The removal of the DNA nucleus from the donated oocyte might be considered the destruction of a potential human life; and the insertion of a DNA nucleus appears to be an asexual creation of a human embryo. We suddenly find ourselves in the middle of the abortion debate. By beginning with hES cells, scientists think this debate could be avoided. However, the use of hES cells does not avoid the embryo problem completely. The Thomson method relies on destroyed blastocysts as the source for hES cells; and the Gearhart method relies on aborted fetuses. Much needs to be cleared up here.

The primary task, as I see it, will be for scientists and ethicists to agree on the relevant vocabulary. In particular, the distinction between totipotent and pluripotent stem cells must be stipulated with sufficient clarityto permit ethical analysis. Right now it appears that only one attribute distinguishes them, namely, a totipotent stem cell has the potential for becoming an embryo and hence a human being, whereas a pluripotent stem cell does not. Yet, we must ask, why is this the case? Is it because totipotent cells have a genetic potential lacking in pluripotent cells? No. What distinguishes them is that totipotent cells have access to a placenta making them available for implantation; whereas pluripotent stem cells lack placenta access. Will this distinction hold? We will see.

Email link | Printer-friendly | Feedback | Contributed by: Dr. Ted Peters

Go to Genetics Topic Index

Ethics Influencing Science?

The Stem Cell Debate: Ethical Questions
What are the New Discoveries?
Stem Cells: What Are They?
The Enormous Potential Value of Stem Cell Research
Question: What's in the Petri Dish, Property or Person?
Question: Will Stem Cell Research Encourage an Increase in Embryo Destruction and Abortions?
Question: What is the Embryonic Status of Totipotent and Pluripotent Stem Cells?
Question: Why is "Derivation" Important?
Question: is There a Potential Baby in Every Body Cell?


Ted Peters

Dr. Ted Peters

See also:
Pain and Suffering
Books on Biology, Genetics and Theology
DNA Double-Helix